Life Coach Sues California Over Free Speech Rights in Psychology Licensing Law

June 4, 2026 - 07:59

Anna Runkle, a well-known life coach who operates under the name "The Crappy Childhood Fairy," has filed a lawsuit against the state of California. She argues that the state's psychology licensing law violates her First Amendment rights by restricting her ability to give paid advice.

Runkle's legal challenge targets California Business and Professions Code Section 2908. This law makes it illegal for unlicensed individuals to offer psychological advice for compensation. Runkle claims this statute is too broad and prevents her from sharing her personal experiences and methods with clients who pay for her coaching services.

The lawsuit, filed in federal court, names Lea Tate, the executive officer of the California Board of Psychology, as the defendant. Runkle argues that her work does not involve diagnosing or treating mental disorders. Instead, she says she offers guidance based on her own life experience and self-help techniques. She believes the state is overstepping by treating her coaching as the practice of psychology.

Runkle's legal team contends that the First Amendment protects the right to give and receive advice, even for a fee. They argue that the state's licensing requirement creates an unconstitutional barrier to free speech. The case raises questions about where the line falls between professional counseling and protected personal expression.

California officials have not yet issued a detailed public response to the lawsuit. The case could set a precedent for how states regulate unlicensed coaches and speakers who offer advice on mental health topics. Legal experts say the outcome may depend on whether courts view Runkle's paid advice as commercial speech or as fully protected expression under the Constitution.